Jewish News

article

In an impassioned address Thursday concerning the ongoing debate over Charedi military conscription, Harav Hagaon Moshe Hillel Hirsch, leader of the yeshiva world, declared that army service is forbidden for all Charedi men, including those not currently studying Torah full-time.

Speaking at a conference of Roshei Yeshiva in Chafetz Chaim, Rav Hirsch addressed the g’zeiras hagiyus, stating that the environment of the IDF is fundamentally incompatible with a Charedi way of life.

“The army is not worthy of a Charedi person,” he stated, citing “questions of chillul Shabbos and arayos, and that is inappropriate.”

He revealed a conversation with a senior government minister to underscore his point. “One of the senior ministers in the government told me, ‘I hope and want a Charedi who enters the army to come out Charedi,’ but he admits that today it is not like that.”

This admission from a government official, Rav Hirsch said, confirms the community’s fears that the military environment leads to a decline in religious observance. He concluded definitively: “Even those who do not study are not allowed to enlist because the army is not at all suitable for the Charedim.”

During his speech, Rav Hirsch also emphasized that physical safety of the Jewish people in Israel is dependent on the zchus of Torah study.

“We need to know what we are doing here in Eretz Yisrael,” he said. “It is written that if the Jews committed sins, the land would vomit them out. So why hasn’t the land vomited us out yet? Because we study Torah.”

He asserted that the continued existence of a Jewish presence in Eretz Yisrael is solely due to the merit of those who learn Torah.  “Torah is magen u’matzla” (Torah shields and saves).

Rav Hirsch added that even a non-Jewish embassy official he spoke with understood the point, saying that “without spirituality… there is no state here. Even the non-Jew understood that without Halacha there is nothing.”