News

article

A federal judge on Friday postponed a decision on whether to throw out a preliminary criminal filing against former FBI Director James Comey, allowing the Justice Department additional time to seek a formal indictment over allegations involving a media leak dating back approximately a decade.

U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden recognized that prosecutors could encounter difficulties securing an indictment. Grand juries in Washington have repeatedly declined to approve charges in politically sensitive investigations. The judge also expressed concern about the possibility of Comey being arrested before prosecutors obtain an indictment, telling the government he would be “extremely frustrated if there’s some sort of dawn raid” against the former FBI chief. Comey’s defense team had raised the possibility of such an arrest.

“That’s not going to happen,” prosecutor Dustin Farahnak assured the court.

Comey’s attorneys asked McFadden to immediately prevent the Justice Department from moving forward with what would be its third criminal prosecution targeting the former FBI director, a prominent critic of President Donald Trump. They argued that prosecutors missed the 10-year deadline for obtaining an indictment and that the alternative document they submitted, known as a “waiverless information,” has no legal standing without Comey’s agreement to surrender his right to a grand jury indictment.

“The criminal information in this case is time-barred and must be dismissed,” said Ephraim McDowell, one of Comey’s attorneys.

Details of Previously Private Legal Proceedings Emerge

Court documents made public Monday disclosed that the Justice Department was pursuing a case against Comey based on allegations concerning a media leak that had already been investigated in 2016. An information is generally used when a defendant gives up the right to have a grand jury consider the charges and plans to plead guilty. Comey, however, has made no such agreement, and his legal team is actively challenging the government’s actions.

Prosecutors argued that filing the information would preserve additional time to obtain a grand jury indictment before the statute of limitations expires. Comey’s lawyers countered that the deadline for bringing the allegations had already passed, making any future indictment legally untimely. They also argued that leaving the case unresolved would unfairly prolong the legal uncertainty facing their client.

“Letting this hang out there pending is a very unfair and unjust result,” McDowell said, later adding that Comey would basically “be sitting here” in limbo “and yet the statute of limitations has run.”

McFadden, who was appointed to the bench by Trump, acknowledged the defense’s argument but made a pointed observation about the difficulty prosecutors have recently encountered when seeking indictments.

“And yet a ham sandwich is harder to indict these days.”

The judge was referring to the familiar expression suggesting that prosecutors traditionally have little difficulty convincing grand juries to approve criminal charges.

Farahnak urged McFadden not to dismiss the case while the grand jury investigation remains underway. He suggested that some of the evidence being presented could involve events occurring after October 2016, potentially placing those allegations within the applicable statute of limitations.

“They may indict, they may not indict,” Farahnak said of the grand jury.

After hearing arguments from both sides, McFadden agreed to postpone his decision rather than immediately dismiss the case.